"A boy sings ... a beautiful thing."
   

 

In Perfect Diapason
(A musical and architectural adventure)

by Martin Carson

Part 6

ON OUR way to Gloucester this morning we find it necessary to visit a vineyard.  Though this activity is of little real interest to Hough and Carson, the vineyard is called "Three Choirs" and so we are willing to make the sacrifice for the sake of choral music.  This clean and pleasing place produces sixteen different labels, and so politeness dictates that we sample most of them and make judicious comment.  We also feel obliged to take home a few in order to support this worthy venture.

We were warned, over our Cheltenham dinner, that Gloucester was not the most attractive of places, "apart from its cathedral, of course"; but, as is ever the case, we find, within minutes of arrival, another interesting place and a helpful soul to interpret it for us.  Not far from our car park is a church with a truncated spire.  Spires are commonplace in our land but unusual ones are more of a rarity than one might expect. On our way to Glossop we saw a really odd one that appears to be leaning, twisted and grooved.  The last of these three it most certainly is not, but the herringbone pattern of the tiles gives this impression. However it has pronounced tilt and is most definitely askew.  Andrew Johnson has a story about this.  He has a story about almost everything and they usually involve, dragons, virgins, stone circles, hollow trees, etc..  The guide book has a more prosaic explanation which, it must be said is exceedingly boring.  One should never repeat it in a pub as a more likely alternative to Andrew's tale.  Being looked at askance will be the best you could expect.  I like the people of Chesterfield as they have left their weird spire to grow crazier and crazier over the years.

The redundant church of St. Whateverherrnamewasbergha in Gloucester has had a most turbulent history and, in this case, the story of the piece bitten out of the spire has tremendous red-herring potential so I shall stay with it.  We wander into the decaying pile to find a young lady scrubbing the font, not at the west end of the nave where one might expect to find it, but in the chapel to the east of the south nave aisle (are you all with me?).  Is she harmless or a predator, I wonder?  Now I know our American friends always assume the best of anyone they find scrubbing fonts which is why they know more about our English history than we do; but we Brits are more cautious.  I avoid eye contact on the first three passes but she is well-trained and pretends not to notice us. Just when we feel it is safe to enter the chancel she strikes.  Escape is impossible for to run the full length of the nave would be rude and that is worse than being caught.  We steel ourselves for the lecture. I suspect we are the first bearded anoraks she has seen all week and she is not going to let us go.

As it turns out, she is very well-informed and her manner is most enticing.  I am just beginning to drop my guard when she mentions Colonel Massey.  Believe me I am not going to captivate you with half an hour of fascinating English history but, to follow my drift for the rest of the paragraph, you need to know that Massey was looking after the City of Gloucester on the 10th August in 1643.  Massey was a Roundhead and this was during our attempt at a civil war. Roundheads were very sensible and proper and virtuous and boring. (As a child I never could understand why alternative cranial dimensions led to such aggravation.  I was much happier in the biology class.)  In the words of an anonymous teacher at Hemyock Primary School (Please do not ask me. I do not know.): "Research by Dr. David Daube of the University of Oxford suggests that nursery rhyme Humpty-Dumpty is based on a popular doggerel original in 1643 - during the time of the Civil War in England. While the King was garrisoned at Oxford at the beginning of the war, a certain Dr. Chillingworth was enrolled by the King's Council of War as expert in sophisticated warfare. On August 10th, 1643, King Charles arrived outside Gloucester, where the Roundhead garrison was commanded by a young Colonel Massey. Dr. Chillingworth suggested three ways of taking the town. The first was to mine under the walls, but this was baulked by rain which flooded the tunnels. The second was to cut off the drinking water and the stream which drove the flour mills but Massey ingeniously pumped water from the Severn, then set up treadmills which were worked by all the citizens of the town.  Chillingworth's third suggestion involved the creation of a siege-engine similar to those used by the Romans. This was a huge machine on wheels which would roll down, bridging the Severn and forming a covered way over the walls of the City. The Romans sometimes called this type of machine a Tortoise and the troops on both sides in the Gloucester siege christened it Humpty-Dumpty. Unfortunately, the citizens found out in advance about the siege-engine and widened the river so that when the machine went into action it could not span the increased width and collapsed into the river from where "all the King's horses and all the King's men. were unable to rescue it.  Despondently on September 5th, the King and his troops marched away unaware that Colonel Massey had only three barrels of powder left for defence of the City.

Why, you may wonder, am I telling you all this?  When I was but a little tiny boy, I sang Humpty Dumpty with my mother, assuming this character to be a large egg with various appendages.  Yes I know that I was perhaps a little gullible at the time, but I am sure you remember the scenario.  If you believe in Santa you get the tricycle as well as the stocking full of tangerines.  If you believe in the tooth fairy, you can earn 100% increase in pocket money on numerous painful occasions during early childhood. Believing that H. Dumpty was an egg was a reasonably safe bet, despite the fact that nobody ever explained the absence of a yolk.  (We are nearly there - please be patient.)  The words of my childhood, apparently embellished by Lewis Carroll's illustrator were as follows:

   Humpty Dumpty sat on a wall,
   Humpty Dumpty had a great fall
   All the king's soldiers and all the king's men
   Could not put Humpty together again.

By the time I had reached my mid-twenties, it was clear to me that saying farewell to teeth was no longer an assured means of earning extra income.  In fact our local dentist expected to be paid for his services.  At the same time Abbey Records released an LP entitled "All the King's Men".  It had a striking cover of a somewhat over-dressed and remarkably clean little drummer boy standing on the brink of a castle moat, strongly resembling that of Bodiam. (Locals tend to say Bodge 'm.)  The record features the boys of Trinity School, Croydon singing this short opera by Richard Rodney Bennett about Colonel Massey's stand against the King.  Colonel Massey was played by Ashley Stafford who became a counter-tenor, sang at St Paul's for many years (and may still do so) and taught Clint van der Linde the art.  Those of you who like Britten's "Golden Vanity" might well like R.R. Bennett's opera.  They have much in common.  The record number is XMS 703 - and it is no use snorting, you who are committed to CDs only, it is not available in this relatively new format.  Perhaps Andrew J., who has just acquired a copy, might be persuaded to encourage its reissue, if enough interest is shown.

Since hearing the opera, I now see Humpty as a great testudo and childhood comfort has evaporated.

   Humpty Dumpty lay in a beck, 
   With all his sinews around his neck
   All the King's doctors and all the King's wrights
   Couldn't put Humpty Dumpty to rights!

. . . and, by the way, it was one of the King's cannon balls which removed the top of the spire.

I learn another lesson in Gloucester.  There is an enormous secondhand-bookshop, almost a department store, with shelves stretching as far as the eye can see.  Martin and I do not need any mutual encouragement at the sight of such places.  We merely walk into them as though it is the most natural thing to do.  This, however is a very special type of shop.  Its unique status dawns on me by about shelf three-hundred-and-seventy-two.  There is not one book that I want. In fact, judging by the stock of unopened, yet ancient, library books they have acquired, nobody else wants them either. All aspiring writers should spend a week in such a shop!

So, at last, we reach the cathedral.  It is hosting a concert tonight by members of the adjacent King's School and so the place resonates with the voices of young musicians preparing to play and sing and of little artists removing a large display of their art and design before term ends.  The building is having great difficulty preserving its dignity and beauty for there are seats, trestles and podia all over the place.  Camera happy Hough looks despairingly at the clutter.  The outside architecture is similarly masked by the scaffolder's art.  However, it is a tribute to both the Cathedral's architects and the musicians of King's Gloucester that its stunning beauty shines through this.  As we explore the intricacies of vault and glass, the choir let rip with: "I was glad when they said unto me - we will go into the house of the Lord."  The school choir successfully overcomes the organist's attempt to drown it; and we too are most glad to be in the house as the 'vivats' ring forth.  The dread deja vu from which I suffer on entering the cloisters is quickly dispersed by Martin's reminding me that this is a scene from Hogwarts.  Now, I am sorry; if you do not know what a Hogwart is then I have nothing but contempt for you.  A poor English author has worked hard to explain all this to the world.  Ignore her at your peril.  While we are pottering about in the lavatorium (see 'monastery') large numbers of children clatter about our heels and fill the Chapter House.  "Zadok the Priest (and Nathan the Prophet) ring forth from the cathedral, owls in abundance perch on the crocketed ogees and the cash registers ring a joyful, zestful peal.  Gloucester Cathedral will survive (especially if they make a sequel). 

Can I leave the nave without mentioning the lady who introduced us to the crypt?  Intoxicated by the glory of the place, she whirls us on a tour of the crypt.  She almost dances with delight at our interest, and we know that this is a well-beloved cathedral, in safe hands, whatever enchantment may befall from celluloid wizardry.

Can I leave the quire without mentioning evensong?  In the words of T. S. Elliot (without permission) " ..it was (you may say) satisfactory.. Was T. S. once a teacher, too, I wonder.

The last stage of our journey will involve no music and no architectural glories.  However, the two Martins have shared a week filled with finely sculpted stone and the music to make it resonate.  We will talk of these things, mile after mile. 

I, Martin Carson, your reporter, can now take this public opportunity to thank Martin Hough, music lover, aesthete, literary critic, gourmet and venerated companion, for his part in making this a most memorable week. I hope a similar journey will be made, in quires and places new, when the singers return to their stalls.

--
Martin Carson
Norfolk  UK

Part Five | Index

Copyright © 2005 Martin Carson - All rights reserved
Used with permission


Copyright © 2005 boychoirs.org
This page was last modified on 06 September 2010